Wiki contents

Journals

2019 Learning journals
2018 Learning journals
2015 Learning journals
2014 Learning journals
2013 Learning journals

Smartsims Support Centre

Blog updates

Recently Updated

Recent updates

Recently Updated

All updates

Skip to end of metadata
Go to start of metadata

In my reflection for this week, I will be attempting two questions: What did I learn this week?  and What does it look like? I will revisit Week 2 because I did not really reflect on the team formation and then write to what some are referring to as the scandal, instead I will refer to as the ‘the situation’.  Lastly, look at the readings for this week regarding leadership and followership.

The team formation has allowed me to meet five very different people who have great vision to want to achieve the excellence in academia.  I learnt that each member has high expectations of themselves as individuals and they recognise the challenges and opportunities of this Management 300 course paper.  As a team - we are learning to talk to one another and not at one another, offer suggestions and solutions, question with sincerity, note requests and requirements, and take on tasks to develop a paper trail of foundational beginnings, redevelop for improvement and implement very positive strategies as a cohesive unit.  We are a team that is constantly reflecting our processes to learn from each other with those with strengths in knowledge of managerial roles or those with weaknesses in technology of the MikesBikes simulation.  In all, learning from each member as manager’s in our own experience (Daudelin, 1996) to adapting to the current team environment with the assistance of reflecting on how we think and behave as a managerial team.

The ‘situation’ that took place this week really does look at the reading of ‘why teams matter’ (Katzenback etal., 1992).  As students being formed into teams to set up pretend organisations; there is an element of trust, belief and if anything, value from team building. Additionally, there is an expectation when you are a man, woman, mother, father, son, daughter etc. to gain a fair deal - out in the real world, but as a university student the expectation is to believe in a fair playing field for all, and not some.  However, I have noticed in a number of learning journals – some students did care about this 'situation' whereas others did not.  Did the situation offer an effective design and management of teams? (Oakley etal., 2004).  No, not in respect to the ‘situation’ and the university does have a strict policy surrounding plagiarism or cheating, whether knowingly or not – is it relevant or irrelevant?  Yes, it is relevant because the ‘situation’ surrounding one team wanting to win the competition (knowingly or not) have since been stripped of that right to compete and on a personal note, I am glad that this team who caused a ‘situation’ and divided our student class for a ‘them versus us’ culture, are being allowed to still work together as a team but denied any extras.  Most importantly, improvements to the CV MikesBikes criteria in the Management 300 course wiki has already been implemented and I hope this situation can never resurface again but there could be a likelihood that word may get out that this is not your ordinary kind of management course paper and to enrol with care.

Lastly, in my new team - our motto has become as I see it, is ‘one for all and all for one’.  I learnt that this team will strive for all and because we are learning focussed, we think to behave as one.  Moreover, the leadership argument that leaders should be a Level 5 leader (Collins, 2005) is so what has happened in my experience with these five wonderful people who see everything as not a problem or an issue and that a very positive solution can be reached in a timely and professional manner.  I agree with Kelley (1988) that bosses are necessarily not good leaders but I would add that with my experience with Fusion Partnerships, the chemistry and real-ness of wanting to work together with the ability to investigate, to improve, to conclude and to move forward is not only followership attributes but of Level 5 leadership qualities too because you can never do everything on your own.  As a result, we are a managerial team of leaders who follow one another in acceptance of our roles and responsibilities, in pursuit of excellence in business.

 

 

Daudelin, M. W. (1996). Learning from experience through reflection. Organizational Dynamics, 24(3), 36--48

Katzenbach, J. R. & Smith, D. K. (1992). Why teams matter. McKinsey Quarterly, (3), 3--27

Oakley, B., Felder, R. M., Brent, R., & Elhajj, I. (2004). Turning student groups into effective teams. Journal of student centred learning, 2(1), 9--34

Collins, J. C. (2005). Level 5 leadership: the triumph of humility and fierce resolve. Harvard Business Review, 83(7/8), 136--146

Kelley, R. E. (1988). In praise of followers. Harvard Business Review, 66(6), 142--148

2 Comments

  1. Ngapoko,

    There is no doubt that you had clear intentions and a strong structure to what you were planning to reflect on and personally, I found that quite refreshing as I have come across many reflections that take a long time to address what they plan on discussing. However, I feel that I had to try extra hard to follow your reflection as quite a lot of your reflection were missing words and punctuation. I only raise this because I felt that it took away from what had the substance to be a very convincing reflection. I would suggest, proof reading it yourself or just asking a friend to proof read it! We've all been there for sure, so don't worry! Also, with this proof reading, you will be able to check whether your writing is fluent and whether the points make sense as at times I felt that you were introducing bits and bobs throughout your piece, where as you should've stuck with the main ideas. But I completely agree with you in regards to the 'situation' and I too hope that there will be measures put in place to rectify this in the future. I wish you and your team all the best but lets hope we're not in the same market cause my team (no offence) will be gunning for you guys cause by the sounds of it a 'managerial team of leaders who follow one another in acceptance of our roles and responsibilities, in pursuit of excellence in business' is something to watch out for!

    All the Best,

    Karen (smile)

    1. Hi Karen

      I work and I did have my writing proof read by two of my closest work colleagues and I don't think, I know they would take great exception to your comments for understanding, punctuation, and grammatical errors, especially they - like me, we already have a degree.  I am back to receive further professional development and this management course is different.  If anything, I am not worried because I like my writing to be critiqued and I certainly know what it is like to work for a professional organization who always wants you to maximize each challenge and opportunity in pursuit of excellence.  I thank you for your feedback.