Wiki contents

Journals

2019 Learning journals
2018 Learning journals
2015 Learning journals
2014 Learning journals
2013 Learning journals

Blog updates

Recently Updated

Recent updates

Recently Updated

All updates

Skip to end of metadata
Go to start of metadata

This week marked the first practice team rollover and revealed the issue of just how ambiguous Mikes Bikes will be.  Deciding how much money to invest in each aspect, such as marketing, was similar to asking how long a piece of string is. I found it difficult to accept that we could not pinpoint a perfect number for each aspect in order to win as it all depended on how the other three teams played their hand.  How could 20% of our grade be left up to chance?  To add to this, we were the predominantly grades-oriented group, winning was definitely our drive.

Spreier, Fontaine and Malloy (2006) explain the drive to achieve and the value of achieving is instilled in us from an early age.  Through primary we are congratulated on being the best in maths or the fastest at running.  Yet in the real business world, apparent achievement may have come at the cost of over pressured employees or rule abiding.  This is often the result of over-achieving managers with achievement motivation who push for high results over too long a period.  This is contradictive to ‘socialized-power’ motivated managers who work through collaboration and bolstering workers.  This could link with Collins’ (2005) ’Level 5 Leader’ which demonstrates great will and humility.  In either of these leaders, winning is not the core focus.  Encouraging workers in their own area emphasizes learning and developing their skills.  I believe our team should work towards socialized power motivation shown through traits of coaching, support and encouragement (Spreier et al., 2006).  

Through this first rollover and overall in this course, I see the emphasis is on learning more than winning.  Learning will not only occur through winning, but through evaluating and reflecting on our not so great decisions.   Therefore, the first rollover may have been ambiguous, however the second rollover will at least provide a situation which we will need to respond to through careful evaluation.  Perhaps when these actions are executed well, we will learn as well as win.

 

References

Collins, J. C. (2005). Level 5 leadership: the triumph of humility and fierce resolveHarvard Business Review, 83(7/8), 136—146

Spreier, S. W., Fontaine, M. H., & Malloy, R. L. (2006). Leadership run amok. Harvard Business Review, 84(6), 72--82

2 Comments

  1. Hi Stephanie,

    First of all I think you had some really interesting ideas. I really liked the conclusions that you came to about this course, that the emphasis should be more on learning than winning. I definitely agree with you and also hope others in our course including my team come to that realisation. I really enjoyed how you have attempted to include all aspects of the course (MikesBikes, readings and teams) together in your journal, as its something I find quite difficult personally. You have definitely shown it can be done!

    In regards all these aspects, I would just say that perhaps my biggest piece of advice is that I felt like when you mentioned the theory in the middle paragraph of your journal it felt slightly separated from your actual experiences. To improve this you could include a bit more of your personal opinions and link it directly to the theory. Overall though I thought you journal was very insightful and I really enjoyed it (smile)

  2. Hi Stephanie

    I liked your clarification right at the beginning of your learning journal for this week that your team is grade oriented to where you want to win - which is a powerfully driven team and then to state that learning is possibly the secret to winning - wow!

    I also enjoyed your use of the theory from the readings this week too - because you can overuse and you clearly have not with clear conclusions as Marama has mentioned in regards to the course.

    A suggestion that you may want to add in your next learning journal, your own expectations that has made you gain great value in a team that is driven to win.  

    Thanks.